Retail for Sale - retail in Ithaca, NY
Retail

Retail for Sale

301 Cayuga Street South, Ithaca, NY 14850

Price

$2,100,000

Square Feet

3,384

Price/Sq Ft

$620.57

Description

Rare development site on edge of Ithaca Downtown Business District. Former Auto Body Shop (3,384 SF) on 0.45 acres to include two (2) parking lots. Prime location and flexible zoning allow for multiple redevelopment opportunities to include apartments and/or retail. Level site with all municipal services.

Property description as provided by the listing source. PropZone adds independent market context, valuation estimates, and comparable listings.

Location

301 Cayuga Street South, Ithaca, NY 14850

Marker
Leaflet © OpenStreetMap contributors

Property Details

Building Size3,384 SF

Market Context

This retail in Ithaca, NY is listed for sale at $2,100,000 across 3,384 SF ($621/SF). It has been on the market for 143 days.

Compare it against other retail listings for sale in Ithaca, NY to benchmark pricing and space — view the full market.

Unified Estimate

Medium Confidence
$95.84/SF-$129.66/SF
Mid: $112.75/SF
Total estimate for 3,384 SF
$381,546

Rate-first confidence-weighted blend with cost-of-business adjustment.

Sale Price History

Market report quarterly trend fallback

Very Low Confidence

Modeled Rate Estimate

$98.66 – $126.84/SF/yr

Estimator modeled rate · mid $112.75

Investment Analysis

Beta Feature: Investment Analysis is currently in beta testing. Metrics are calculated based on available financial data and market comparables. Results are for informational purposes and should not be considered financial advice. Verify all assumptions and consult with a financial advisor before making investment decisions.

Financing Assumptions

Insufficient financial data for full analysis. Add more financial fields to improve metric coverage.

Market Employment Trend

YoY Growth:+0.2%
Avg Weekly Wage:$2,004

December 2025 • Source: BLS QCEW

Economic Indicators

30-Yr Mortgage:6.47%
CPI Inflation (YoY):4.2%

Source: FRED

Market Demographics

Census ACS 2024
Population104,537
Median Income$74k
College Educated43.1%↑ 9.7pp
Median Age32.3 yrs
Median Home Value$291k
Unemployment5.5%↑ 1.9pp

2024 American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates •Released annually by U.S. Census Bureau

Price per Square Foot

$620.57

196.9% above market

Asking price / 3,384 sqft

Assumptions
  • Interest rate: 6.47% (FRED live)
  • Loan term: 25 years
  • Down payment: 25.0%
  • Market comparison: retail in Ithaca, NY

More Retail for Sale in Ithaca, NY(5)

Contact Broker

Listed by

Cushman & Wakefield